thumbnail-v4

Make an appointment today to discover how our expertise in practice branding, patient acquisition, advanced marketing tactics, and patient retention can help you thrive.

Recent Posts
Sign-Up for the "The Definitive Guide" Book

Steve Schwartz reveals secrets to successful marketing campaigns and growth strategies for the concierge medical industry, this guide draws from 25 years of digital marketing expertise and experience working with over 900 clients.

thumbnail-v4
Concierge Medical Marketing Podcast Launching a Membership Practice Without Legal Landmines | Ep 57
November 13, 2026

Listen on Spotify: Launching a Membership Practice Without Legal Landmines — Episode 57

Before a concierge or DPC practice takes its first member, a handful of legal decisions decide whether it's protected as it grows. In this episode, Steven talks with Jonna Eimer — Chicago health care attorney, Shareholder at Roetzel & Andress, and chair of the firm's healthcare practice group — about getting that foundation right the first time.

Jonna's first piece of advice is sequencing: the very first legal decision is what kind of entity to form (many states require a professional entity), and right behind it comes the fork in the road — will the practice take insurance (Medicare only, or Medicare plus commercial, which she calls "tricky and more complicated") or go cash-based from the start? The structure and the agreements all get built around that answer. The cost surprises most people: entity filing runs $50 to a few hundred dollars, a membership agreement takes roughly two to five hours to prepare, and the whole initial legal outlay is about three to seven hours — as Jonna puts it, legal fees "really shouldn't be" the big startup expense; the lease is.

From there: why an AI-drafted agreement can end up costing more than starting from an attorney's proven forms; why open AI tools are a problem for PHI and for attorney-client privilege (what you type in can be discoverable in litigation, while closed systems protect it); the questions to ask an attorney before hiring one — what documents they'll prepare, how many hours it should take, whether they'll flag it early if the budget will be exceeded, and why the lowest hourly rate can produce the highest total bill; and the four must-haves of a membership agreement: the covered services spelled out specifically, the fee and payment terms fully transparent, termination and refund provisions, and insurance — taking it or not — specifically defined. She closes with her advice for any provider on the fence about the membership model: "Do it. Make the switch… I don't have any clients that have regretted the change."

Guest: Jonna Eimer, Roetzel & Andress — [email protected]
Book a call with Steven: https://cmmkg.com/schedule
Free resources for membership practices: stevenschwartz.info

Chapters

  • 00:00 — Meet Jonna Eimer: a geeky kid who always wanted to be a lawyer
  • ~04:03 — From corporate deals to health care law (and a cardiologist husband)
  • ~05:31 — First hearing of concierge medicine: the fearful hybrid years
  • ~07:40 — Decision #1: what kind of entity to form
  • ~08:45 — Insurance or cash-pay? The fork that shapes everything else
  • ~10:33 — What startup legal work actually costs (3–7 hours; filing $50–a few hundred)
  • ~12:05 — AI-drafted documents: when "saving money" adds cost
  • ~14:46 — AI on the marketing side: the Practice Growth Assessment
  • ~16:05 — Open vs. closed AI: PHI, discoverability, and privilege
  • ~19:38 — Questions to ask an attorney before you hire one
  • ~23:00 — Membership agreement must-haves: services, fees, termination, insurance
  • ~25:11 — The attorney as general counsel: audits, HR, and who's-who referrals
  • ~27:50 — The new models: longevity, hormone, and functional medicine practices
  • ~31:32 — On the fence? "Do it — make the switch" (no client has regretted it)
  • ~32:54 — How to reach Jonna, plus Steven's free resources and book

About Our Guest

Jonna Eimer, Shareholder at Roetzel & Andress, Chicago — chair of the firm’s healthcare practice group. She focuses on the legal architecture of membership medicine: concierge, direct primary care (DPC), and cash-pay practices.

Visit Jonna’s firm bio  |  [email protected]

Book a call with Steven  |  Free resources for membership practices: stevenschwartz.info

Full Transcript

Timestamps are approximate. Passages that fell between screen scrolls in the capture are marked [passage not captured].

[00:00] Steven Schwartz: Hello and welcome to the Concierge Medical Marketing Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Schwartz. It's my pleasure to have you along with us today. I'm thrilled to interview Jonna Eimer. Jonna, did I say your name right?

Jonna D Eimer: You did. It's a hard one. Thanks for having me.

Steven Schwartz: Thank you. Jonna is an attorney and she's with Roetzel & Andress. Did I say that right?

Jonna D Eimer: Yep — Roetzel, like pretzel. I know. My name is hard; my firm is Roetzel, like pretzel.

[~00:30–01:20] Steven Schwartz: I should have asked you that before. And I'm thrilled to have met you recently at the Concierge Medical Forum in Cumming, Georgia, just really a couple of weeks ago. And I love that conference. Michael Tatro is such a great guy and pulls together such an amazing conference every year. So for folks who are involved in concierge medicine or direct primary care, or even if you're considering getting involved, I strongly recommend: make your way to the conference. It's in October every year. And really, it's an eye-opening experience. You'll meet so many amazing folks while you're there. Obviously, be sure to like and subscribe to the podcast wherever you do your podcasting — Spotify or Apple Podcasts or Amazon, all that kind of stuff. That really helps us get the word out there about what we do and what we share here on our podcast. But Jonna, we met at the conference, had a really nice conversation. I remember thinking, I've got to interview you for the podcast. You've got a lot of [passage not captured]

[Steven, reading her background:]* …she's based in Chicago, she's the chair of the healthcare practice group at Roetzel & Andress. She focuses her practice on healthcare and in the healthcare industry. She's a lawyer that specializes in concierge medicine, direct primary care, membership medicine, and also physicians in private practice in other ways…

Steven Schwartz: Wow, that's great. Thank you. So tell me…

[~02:49] Jonna D Eimer: Chicago. I'm very local, but my practice spans across the states to various locations, with various doctors in different locations. But yeah, I was one of those kind of, you know, serious, geeky kids that always wanted to be a lawyer. I always knew I wanted to do it. So I think I've been saying I was going to be a lawyer since I was little. And lo and behold, here I am, thirty some odd years later. But I've loved it. I've always loved practicing. And my father was a lawyer. He loved it, and I think I knew I would like it too — and I do.

Steven Schwartz: Fantastic. It's funny when you mention that — it's 30 years, my goodness. I thought maybe 10 years, because you look so young and vibrant.

Jonna D Eimer: Oh, thank you.

[~04:03] Jonna D Eimer: …law school, and when I first started practicing I wanted to do transactional corporate law. That was always something I was interested in. And frankly, when I first started in law, healthcare law groups weren't even a thing. They were just kind of part of the rest of the legal groups, corporate groups, whatever. So it wasn't even a specialty. So early on I started doing some deals in the corporate medical space.

And another aside is my husband's a cardiologist, so I probably was just naturally interested in it. He wasn't in a place that he needed help or anything like that — he was a fellow at that point. But I think I've just gravitated towards it because it was interesting, and then got deeper into it and really just enjoyed it, and enjoyed working with other professionals like myself. I could relate to their entrepreneurial issues as well as their licensing issues and professionalism. So I felt like it was just a really interesting, good fit. And it's [passage not captured]

[~05:31] Steven Schwartz: Do you have any specific memories of when you first heard the concept of concierge medicine or this membership model and thought, "What the heck is this? This is so different"? Any memories like that?

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, I do remember early on, probably like fifteen, twenty years ago, first seeing and talking about it even at a conference early on, and really specifically addressing a hybrid approach. Because I think at that point the concept was so new, and the practices when it first came out that I was representing, and they were considering moving to this type of model, were really fearful. Right? "What if patients just revolt and they don't want this type of service, or they won't pay for it?" Nobody — you know, since we have insurance and people have Medicare, they didn't know if the public would be willing to pay additional amounts of money [passage not captured]

[~07:01] Steven Schwartz: Excellent. Yeah, we've seen so much growth in the last couple of years. Here in my little town of Vero Beach, Florida, Cleveland Clinic came in maybe three or four years ago and bought the hospital, and then started purchasing the separate medical practices. And some providers chose not to sell, or in some cases sold, got out, started their own concierge practice and haven't looked back. And others sold, stayed with the practice for two years, then left and then started a concierge practice. So here in our little town we have so many.

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, I've seen that too. I've represented clients like that — where they were private, they sold to a health system, and then they again went back to being private and did some sort of concierge or cash-based model. So I've seen that as well. It's been interesting to see.

Steven Schwartz: Yes, it's cool seeing the trends. So let's say a provider's listening to this podcast and they're thinking about opening up their own concierge or DPC practice. What are some of the first and most important initial legal considerations that practitioner should be aware of, and make good decisions about, from the get-go?

[~07:40] Jonna D Eimer: Well, I would say initially, from the get-go, the first legal consideration you'll make is what kind of entity to form. In Illinois, and in a lot of states, it's often required to be a professional entity, like a professional limited liability [passage not captured]

Jonna D Eimer: …like, what do you want to do? What are your expectations? What kind of services do you want to provide? What are your expectations of availability? And so I just get first just a really kind of casual conversation about what they want to do, so then we can start figuring out how to structure it legally.

And so one of those early questions, after I kind of get an understanding of what they're interested in doing — one of the first questions is: are you going to take insurance or not? Because I have concierge practices that do take Medicare only, or take Medicare plus commercial insurance, which is tricky and more complicated, and more vetting needs to happen. And then I have ones who know from the start that they're only going to do cash-based. And so I just need to know that from the start, before we start structuring and preparing agreements — what are their ideas, where do they see it going? And then we build the structure to be legally compliant around what they want.

[~10:33] Jonna D Eimer: …corporate entity filing. It could be anywhere from fifty dollars to a few hundred. And, you know, we can help with your EIN. If you need to register with the local licensing authority, we can help with all that. And then it's basically just preparing your operating or organizational documents, and then it takes some time to prepare a patient agreement, if you need a patient membership agreement. And these agreements take on average — I will estimate two to four or five hours, depending on how elaborate they want, what state they're in, what type of practice they have. I'd say that really the outlay initially is about three to seven hours. That's about my estimate. So it's really not a lot, honestly, and it's not very expensive for a professional to go in and do this the right way from the start. So if you're starting a new practice, or you're in business, you can be, you know, conservative, right? And if you have a, you know, a regular [passage not captured]

[~11:53] Jonna D Eimer: …program that they want to do, it really isn't a lot of lawyer time. The lawyers come in later, I feel like, when you're growing, hopefully, and you need us more. So the outlay [is] not —

Steven Schwartz: No, that's really great.

Jonna D Eimer: — seems to be your lease, all those other things are going to be your big expenses starting. You know, it really shouldn't be the legal fees.

Steven Schwartz: That's great. Obviously more and more people are using AI in their businesses. And do you have cases where people come to you and say, "Hey, I've worked with my Gemini or ChatGPT or Claude or whatever — I drafted this the best I could. Can you look [passage not captured]"

[~13:12] Jonna D Eimer: …your patient comes to you and they've done all this Google searching, and then you're going down these, like, what doctors often call fishing expeditions — they have to look into all these other things now that really don't seem applicable. So I've had that happen with clients, where of course if they give me something — and they're usually doing it because they're trying to figure it out, save costs — sometimes it can add costs, because now I'm trying to go down all their rabbit holes of different things. And so sometimes what I get is more complicated, and I'm doing all this additional research, than starting with one of the kind of forms that I've used before. So while I welcome their usage, and I understand the inclination, it can sometimes add costs, not save costs — where if I use it efficiently and effectively, it should save costs. Right? That's the idea. That's how I want to use it for people, but I understand we all want to use it because it's such a powerful, interesting tool. So I would never tell someone not to use it. But when they send me a really long or marked-up [passage not captured]

[~14:46] Steven Schwartz: Absolutely. You mentioned AI. In my agency, I use AI literally all day long, in so many different areas and projects and things that I do. One of the things that I've launched recently is a Practice Growth Assessment, or PGA. And I can literally add a website address into the PGA system and it will go to that website, research the medical practice, basically read through the entire website, make a list of quick wins — these are items that the practitioner could easily fix, change, tweak, add, or remove to make the website more effective, more accurate, more helpful, more useful, better ranking on Google, better ranking on AI. And not just all that, but then it also looks at the competitors in the area and analyzes them. And how does that stack up? [passage not captured]

[~16:05] Steven Schwartz: …better on these things? And the answer is sure, of course. Let's talk about it.

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, yeah, no, I agree. It's so interesting. And another thing from our perspective — just like with medical professionals, you have PHI that you don't want disclosed — what I always tell clients too is if they're using an open-source AI like ChatGPT, it's not protected. So not only is their information being fed into the public to teach the models, but it's also — if there is litigation — that has been discoverable in litigation. So yours is not necessarily — what I'm doing on my internal computer is a closed source, right? It's not, it can't be accessed by other people, it's all protected. So it maintains the attorney [passage not captured — passage turns on attorney-client privilege]

[~17:13] Jonna D Eimer: Me too. Yeah.

Steven Schwartz: …do, not what I get. You don't want me doing your heart surgery, or, you know, filling your teeth or doing a root canal.

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah. Yeah.

Steven Schwartz: That's not my thing. But yeah, with the right AI tools, I can do amazing things for our clients. With the right AI tools, you can do amazing things for your clients. In fact, I think we're gonna be seeing a lot more cases of closed AI systems being deployed at small, medium, and large businesses, so that the intellectual property can be kept private, kept out of the bigger [passage not captured]

[~18:21] Steven Schwartz: …but people who don't really know the rules chat-GPT'd their issue or gripe. They put it on there, and he responds, he says, "Well, I can tell that you used AI to formulate your answer here. Here's what it actually says in the rule book." And you know, so [passage not captured]

[~19:38] Steven Schwartz: …worked at a hospital system, they haven't had to use an attorney for anything, or much, before. And now they're a business owner. And what are some questions that you would encourage a practitioner to ask attorney candidates that they are interviewing for the job of being my counsel? What questions should they be asking of people like you?

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, well, like we talked about: what would be a reasonable amount of time? Once they explain what they want to do, then I would expect the attorney to come back and say, "These are the documents that I think we need." And then I would, as a client, say, "Well, how many hours of time do you think that will take?" And I think it's a fair estimate — you know, depending on what they want and how many agreements — to give. And I often do it as a range, just to give myself a little cushion, because I don't know. Sometimes things come up, and I don't want them to be [passage not captured]

[~20:59] Jonna D Eimer: And will you advise me, you know, as soon as possible if you think it's going to be different? Right? If new developments come up or new things — if I'm acting in such a way, or asking questions or multiple phone calls — please tell me quickly if you think we're going to exceed that budget, so I can recalculate. And I always say too, I work for the client, right? So I will defer to whatever their wishes are. And if they say, "Hey, spend this much time and then let's discuss," or "just let me know when we're at that amount of time, and let's put a stopper on it at that point." So all those questions are completely fair. What are they providing, what documents are they providing, and how many hours of time do they expect it to take? And to keep you informed along the way if anything changes. All those are — and to ask their appropriate level of experience as well. And if they've done a bunch of this, then they should be able to give you that reasonable fee [passage not captured]

[~22:17] Jonna D Eimer: …you know, lower rates, whether it's paralegal or junior colleagues, wherever I can, to save time and money. Forming the entity, all those kind of administrative filing tasks — those are all perfect for that. But sometimes, you know, you never know — just because an attorney has a lower hourly rate, it doesn't mean it's going to be cheaper for you. If they don't do this frequently, it might take them a lot more time, for instance, than it takes someone who's more seasoned and does it frequently. You know, so the hourly rate, I think, is less important than the total cost and time involved — because if their rate is low but they say it's gonna take five to eight hours of time, well, you're kind of coming out at the same place, or worse, because you don't have the level of experience that was needed, or maybe would have been useful, for the agreement. So I think all those things are appropriate and should be asked of any [passage not captured]

[Passage captured via the "Essential Elements" Magic Clip, in sequence:]

Steven Schwartz: So what absolutely has to be in a membership agreement to protect the practice?

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, so the first is covered services. What services are covered by that fee? Because you're getting a membership fee — obviously, if a patient does not receive those services, the patient is going to be very angry and can go complain to a licensing board. And so it has to be very, very specific about what services are covered. The second thing is the fee itself — and actually the fee, it's the charge, it's the services, it's the specifics about the services, and the payment terms. Is it monthly, is it quarterly, is it annually? And so on and so forth. Any time — what [the] patient pays to join, how often they pay, and when it's due.

[~23:42] Jonna D Eimer: Is it quarterly, is it annually? So the services, the fee itself, has to be completely transparent — when it's due. And I would say also termination — you know, termination and refund provisions. Those are extremely important. And maybe as a fourth: obviously, if you're taking or not taking insurance, that is very, very important and has to be specifically defined and explained in the agreement. Those are the must-haves, you know. And then beyond that, you want to make sure that whatever that patient agreement says is in line with whatever other information you have out there — like your marketing information on your website, other flyers and things you might have when patients come in. You want all this communication to be consistent, so that the patient has a very clear understanding of what they're paying for, what they're getting, and their expectations are appropriate to the services being offered.

[~25:11] Jonna D Eimer: …like general counsel to these practices on things that come up. So they often reach out to me, you know, on "who do you recommend for a consultant?" or "I have an issue with a payer audit," or "I have an HR issue," right? Or "do you know a good accountant? Do you know a good marketing person like you?" So all those places come together, I think, oftentimes at the attorney level. So those are the fun stuff, where you get to know about the practice and you get to kind of be birthed with it and then grow with it. And so you really become familiar with the practice and the providers as they grow, and the concerns and the risks.

So I think that is one of the most rewarding parts of acting as their advisor and business consultant, when I get to, right? But every relationship is different, but it's certainly enjoyable and rewarding to be able to provide those benefits when you can.

[~26:27] Steven Schwartz: …that productive guidance makes a huge difference. And I'm sure it's —

Jonna D Eimer: Thank you.

Steven Schwartz: — very rewarding for you when you lay your head on the pillow in the evening.

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, I agree with you. They are great people to work with. I would say doctors and healthcare providers generally are really, in my experience, kind, good people. They went into this to help people. So I am very lucky. I have very, very nice clients, almost all the time, really. So it is very rewarding. And so many of them, because the models are so different — there's certainly the ones that I represent that are at these very, you know, kind of elite, fancy [passage not captured]

[~27:50] Jonna D Eimer: …and I'm sure they do good work too, but the volume they're expected to see doesn't allow for that. So I think it's great that the market allows for all these innovations, and it's a really fun time to see it working, and working so interestingly for so many different people.

Steven Schwartz: Right. I've really been intrigued how so many different practices truly create the practice the way they want it. One that I was speaking with earlier today is actually outside of Chicago as well. And they want to have a practice that focuses on longevity and hormone replacement, and things along [passage not captured]

[~28:59] Steven Schwartz: …patients on the panel. So part of the arrangement that they're thinking of doing is the hybrid practice, where they're going to hire an NP or a PA to handle the insurance-based patients, and working with us to build a brand new website promoting the membership VIP level care. And in doing so, we do that website, we do the marketing, and obviously in the Chicago area there's so many people who are searching for phrases on Google and AI tools right now that we're going to help them fill their panel, you know, in the next twelve to twenty-four months. So it's really exciting.

Jonna D Eimer: That's great. That's such a great service to offer. And I've seen a bunch of that in my practice as well, where it used to be a lot of primary care — and there still are, for sure, a lot of primary care physicians doing concierge care — but I am seeing all these other models, like you're saying, whether it's hormone or other, like, functional medicine, longevity.

[~30:15] Jonna D Eimer: Yeah.

Steven Schwartz: And so instead of having a panel of 300 or 400, she went down to 150 or maybe 200. And it was only the harder cases, and —

Jonna D Eimer: Not.

Steven Schwartz: — left her colleagues to work with the other patients, who are the more typical, standard, easier —

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah. Yeah.

[~31:32] Steven Schwartz: Definitely. Well, as we wrap up this conversation — I really enjoy this, Jonna — the last question I have for you: for a provider who's on the fence about going into the membership route of medicine and health delivery, what's your one piece of advice?

Jonna D Eimer: I would say do it. Make the switch. If you're already disillusioned — you're kind of thinking that way — and not necessarily disillusioned, but you're looking for a change, right? A new, kind of invigorating new practice model. I don't have any clients that have regretted — knock on wood — regretted the change and the move to doing this. They've all gone into it with very reasonable expectations, and I think they've all been really kind of pleasantly surprised how well it's gone. So I have some that just go full speed from the beginning, just gangbusters; some, it goes a little slower. So every provider, it can be a little different. So I have some that maybe they'll stay [passage not captured]

[~32:54] Jonna D Eimer: …not one [client has said], "I'm gonna go back to insurance medicine." Not one. [Reconstructed from a garbled ASR passage — see correction #9.]

Jonna D Eimer: Yeah. Yeah. Same. Same. I haven't had one yet.

Steven Schwartz: I was just gonna say — this has been a wonderful conversation, and you bring so much to this space with your knowledge and your experience. If any of our audience would like to speak with you — maybe have a couple of quick questions, or are ready to consider engaging you and your law firm to help them with whatever legal issue or situation or documents with their medical practice — how can they best get in touch with you?

Jonna D Eimer: They can call me, they can email me — anything. Anything is good. I respond to anything. It's [email protected]. Please reach out. I'd love to help.

[~34:14] Jonna D Eimer: Yeah, yeah, I love Chicago.

Steven Schwartz: I was gonna say — for existing practices in the membership space, or those that are considering starting a membership practice, I've created a website that has tons of free resources that are absolutely available for you to request and download and utilize to your heart's content. I created a website, stevenschwartz.info — stevenschwartz.info. And just about everything on there is free. There's one thing that we do charge for, because I need to bring in the team to do the work on it. But I encourage anybody who's listening: please take a look at that website, and if there's anything there that's helpful to you, please fill out the form, or whatever. How it works is: you click it, read about it. If you want that free resource, put in your first name. [In the clip, this continues: last name, email… send that information… that team… and in doing so, you know, I hope you…]

[~35:42, to 36:32] Steven Schwartz: …big PDF that you're welcome to download from our website. It's totally free. Visit conciergemd.marketing — that's our agency website. Scroll down, see a copy of the book, and literally just put in your email, hit the go button, and it will email you a link where you can download the book. So please take that with my compliments, use it to your ability to grow your practice. Obviously, if you want to speak to me about your specific growth plans, goals, and challenges in marketing your practice, I'm happy to speak with you about that. Jonna Eimer, from Roetzel & Andress in Chicago — thank you —

[~36:27] Steven Schwartz: …so much. I got it right. Thank you so much for being my guest on the Concierge Medical Marketing Podcast. It's truly been awesome getting to know you and learning more about you, and hearing your heart and your passion for this space. So thank you for being here.

Jonna D Eimer: Thank you, Steve. Thanks for having me. It's been great.

Steven Schwartz: My pleasure. And again, folks, thanks for joining us on the Concierge Medical Marketing Podcast. Please like, share, subscribe, repost — whatever you want to do, whatever you can do — so that you can get more of this content in the future, and so that more people in our space can get this free information. Okay — Steve Schwartz, Concierge Medical Marketing Podcast; my guest, Jonna Eimer. And folks, take care. Have a great day, and we'll see you on our next episode. Goodbye for now.

— End of transcript, 36:32 —